Psychobabble or Spiritual Journey?

Jordan Peterson's Personal Map of Meaning

Look around the room you’re in. Go ahead. Look. Try to remember everything in the room that is black. Now close your eyes and recall everything you saw that was red. You can’t. Because you weren’t looking for red. You were looking for black. More about this in a moment.

I’ve been following Jordan Peterson for a few years now. And by following, I should say that I have watched the entire Exodus seminar and the Gospels seminar, as well as many hours of podcasts, YouTube clips, and his interviews on various shows and podcasts. So yeah, I’ve been going to Peterson academy for years before the institution opened. I’ve learned to understand him like an uncle that isn’t perfect but is pretty cool most of the time.

How He Got Here

Peterson came onto the public scene speaking out against a bill in Canada compelling speech. He spent many years studying the worst people in modern history, Hitler, Stalin, and Mao. His conclusions were a) the thread of lies and b) not speaking up were constant in all three monsters. His primary argument to the bill was that it was one thing to place policy restrictions on speech, but it is an entirely different issue to compel speech. Telling someone what they must say was overboard, from his perspective. This led to an outcry from two directions. One group of people believed that because he did not want the government to have control of his tongue, this meant he was averse to trans issues and attacked him on social media for his stance. Another group felt that because he was standing on a principle of free speech, he was to be applauded and was supported on social media. This level of attention thrust him into the spotlight.

Fast forward and he has been evolving over time into more of a philosophical lecturer, calling young men to “Make their beds”. He dives into aspects of human behavior and how to maximize potential. He began lecturing around the world on issues of boundaries (12 rules for life) and aiming towards the ineffable transcendent as a deterministic view of beneficial outcome (We who wrestle with God). He sits down with other thinkers and sorts out issues of interest in a conversational style investigation. Anyone he thinks is interesting, he talks to them.

The Attacks

But here lately there is an assault on his cognitive abilities, genuine motivation, and his possible deterioration into a neonationalist position. The critique is that he has lost his mind. He is being accused of one-sided, tribalistic, psycho-babbling fury with no coherent thoughts or direction to his mental linguistic formulation. Some blame the detox from Benzos. Some blame being hired by the Daily Wire or his alignment with Joe Rogan. Some claim he is just getting old. But when I looked into the various critiques for merit, I saw a theme. Each person levying insults, disguised as concern, were openly anti-religion and anti-Zionist elitists.

My Personal Take on JBP

Peterson is certainly not without his faults. His speeches and his books are often hard to follow. I’ve read both of his 12 rules books and have begun the new book, We Who Wrestle with God, and chapters begin with a theme, tell a story or two, then leave that thought to chase another thought that sparked something in his mind. He eventually comes back to the original thought and makes it all join together somehow. I’m still not sure how he does it. But if you are looking for the brilliance in it, it is not difficult to find. If you are looking for psychobabble, that’s easy to find too. Remember, you weren’t looking for red, you were looking for black. His speeches are no different. Except, he is very open and honest about how his lectures will go. He states that each night, he starts with a single thought, then explores and investigates that thought in front of the audience. This can lend itself to a myriad of possibilities in thought. The people that pay for tickets to see him know this and enjoy watching this unfold. It relies on his brilliance. And we all just sit in awe. I have attended two and they did not disappoint.

He also talks way too much in his podcast interviews. He has someone on, asks them a question, and as they get part of the way into their response he jumps in and branches the conversation off into the thought that jumped into his head. Sometimes, the guest gets visibly frustrated. He does this more when it is a subject that irritates him, like gender-affirming care (As though that exists). So I get the frustration with his delivery and perceived unawareness, though he is aware he talks too much. But why the character attack?

True colors shine when he starts talking about religion or Israel. This is where the attacks are coming from. I recently read a Substack article destroying his character and there were 64 comments, which is a lot for Substack. Every single comment jumped on the hate train and most commenters included in their vitriol-filled response some vile disdain for Jewish people, Christians, and anyone who believes in anything beyond physical matter. If you want to piss these people off, start talking about “an ineffable, transcendent God of the Hebrews.”

Peterson’s Spiritual Journey

Jordan Peterson has clearly been on a personal religious journey for the last few years. Originally, his scientific brain would not allow such exploration. It was when he began to explore various religious texts for a deeper philosophical understanding of Being that he found himself challenged and intrigued. He landed on biblical texts as a personal preference, starting with a seminar on the book of Genesis. In the midst of this, he almost died, his wife almost died, and his daughter almost died. His wife had a religious experience and credited God with the blessing of living a longer life. Peterson and his daughter watched in awe. Peterson then explored the Exodus story. Then the Gospels. He began talking to people who were more knowledgeable about religious experience than he was. This was bound to bring out the hate, and it did. The obvious connection to Israel was his appreciation for religious Judaism. Peterson is going through self-discovery of spirituality in front of the world. And to me, it is fun to watch.

Conclusion

What I learned about Peterson before, and what I know about him now is that at the core of who he is, he wants individuals to be the best versions of themselves they can possibly be. He harbors no hate towards anyone. He processes everything from a psychological lens. It’s the only way he can comprehend it. He gets emotional about some things and loses track of the important parts of his position at times. But he only wants to help people be better versions of themselves. He has no desire to tell people what to do. And he believes firmly in standing up against outright lies, like sexual transitioning will fix one’s gender dysphoria. There is documented evidence that will not happen, and he is willing to say the hard part out loud.

So, like him or hate him, his intentions and motivations behind what he does and says are incredibly pure. His delivery is suspect at times. His insistence on oversharing can be off-putting. But his passion for truth, justice, wisdom, knowledge, and the betterment of all people cannot be overstated. He’s human. He’s imperfect. But he’s a pretty good human. Ok, now I need to go make my bed.

Stay Classy GP!

Grainger